20th Century Paddy: The Songs of Shane MacGowan– Album Review
With roughly 200 songs across a career spanning The Nips, The Pogues and The Popes, choosing the best of Shane MacGowan's work was always going to be a challenge. Finding artists who could record those songs and do them justice was another matter entirely. Yet that's exactly what Victoria Mary Clarke and those involved with 20th Century Paddy: The Songs of Shane MacGowan
have managed to do.
Across 36 tracks, this isn't your typical tribute album. Instead, it's a showcase of songwriting from one of Ireland's finest, bringing together an A-list cast of Irish musicians, international stars and friends MacGowan gathered throughout a career spanning almost five decades.
The beauty of 20th Century Paddy
is hearing MacGowan's songs recorded differently, all in one place. Part of The Pogues' charm was how their music often sounded as though it was about to fall apart, but somehow never did. Here, the recordings are more polished, yet they still manage to retain the spirit of MacGowan.
And that's down to the songwriting. MacGowan was a punk poet with Celtic blood whose songs could easily cross over from the raggle-taggle sound of The Pogues to smooth, studio-perfect recordings. The artists here aren't trying to copy his sound. They're simply recording the songs for what they are: great songs.
Before the album arrived, we got a taste of what to expect. Bruce Springsteen's A Rainy Night in Soho
was the first single, followed by Johnny Depp and Imelda May's Haunted, Kingfishr's The Sunnyside of the Street, Glen Hansard's Bottle of Smoke and U2's Yeah, Yeah, Yeah, Yeah, Yeah.
Dropkick Murphys took on The Body of an American, while LYRA recorded Streets of Sorrow / Birmingham Six. Hozier and Jessie Buckley's version of Fairytale of New York
arrived alongside the album, tackling perhaps the most difficult MacGowan song to cover, given how closely it's associated with Shane and Kirsty MacColl.
The album also features some of Ireland's finest musicians, including Picture This, Amble, Mundy, Damien Dempsey, Bob Geldof, Liam Ó Maonlaí and Tom Creagh. International contributors include Steve Earle, David Gray, The Jesus and Mary Chain, Tom Waits, Kate Moss and Primal Scream.
Primal Scream's version of A Pair of Brown Eyes
is particularly interesting, with jangling guitars reminiscent of The Byrds, who themselves famously covered Bob Dylan. It's a fitting comparison, considering both Dylan and MacGowan's ability to write songs that can be completely transformed without losing what makes them great.
There's also a sadness surrounding parts of 20th Century Paddy
. The late Moya Brennan of Clannad appears on Mother Mo Chroi
, a recording made towards the end of her life. Her contribution is another reminder of the remarkable collection of musicians brought together to celebrate MacGowan's songwriting.
And of course, the album wouldn't be complete without Shane himself. Cronin's version of London You're a Lady
includes spoken words from MacGowan, reflecting on London's multicultural richness and how the people who call it home give the city its soul. It's a fitting addition to a collection celebrating his work.
20th Century Paddy: The Songs of Shane MacGowan
is folk, punk, pop, rock and everything in between. If you're looking for an album that sounds like a Pogues tribute band, this isn't it. Instead, each artist has put their own spin on the songs without trying to reinvent them.
What makes the album work is how it strips away some of the rough edges and highlights just how good MacGowan was as a complete songwriter, both lyrically and musically. These songs don't need Shane's unmistakable voice or The Pogues' chaotic arrangements to stand up on their own.
Victoria Mary Clarke and everyone involved have put together a fitting celebration of one of Ireland's greatest songwriters. It's not about replacing the originals, but showing that beneath all the chaos, Shane MacGowan wrote songs that will continue to be recorded and enjoyed for generations to come.
READ MORE | The Best Irish Music Right Now